Honest Argument - Node: Long history of Christian War on Christmas

Argument:	There is no War on Christmas
Node type:	This node supports its parent
Parent node:	The thesis is the parent
Node Text:	Long history of Christian War on Christmas From the NYT: The Puritans considered Christmas un-Christian, and hoped to keep it out of America. They could not find Dec. 25 in the Bible, their sole source of religious guidance, and insisted that the date derived from Saturnalia, the Roman heathens' wintertime celebration. On their first Dec. 25 in the New World, in 1620, the Puritans worked on building projects and ostentatiously ignored the holiday. From 1659 to 1681 Massachusetts went further, making celebrating Christmas "by forbearing of labor, feasting or in any other way" a crime. The concern that Christmas distracted from religious piety continued even after Puritanism waned. In 1827, an Episcopal bishop lamented that the Devil had stolen Christmas "and converted it into a day of worldly festivity, shooting and swearing." Throughout the 1800's, many religious leaders were still trying to hold the line. As late as 1855, New York newspapers reported that Presbyterian, Baptist and Methodist churches were closed on Dec. 25 because "they do not accept the day as a Holy One." On the eve of the Civil War, Christmas was recognized in just 18 states. Christmas gained popularity when it was transformed into a domestic celebration, after the publication of Clement Clarke Moore's "Visit from St. Nicholas" and Thomas Nast's Harper's Weekly drawings, which created the image of a white-bearded Santa who gave gifts to children. The new emphasis lessened religious leaders' worries that the holiday would be given over to drinking and swearing, but it introduced another concern: commercialism. By the 1920's, the retail industry had adopted Christmas as its own, sponsoring annual ceremonies to kick off the "Christmas shopping season." Religious leaders objected strongly. The Christmas that emerged had an inherent tension: merchants tried to make it about buying, while clergymen tried to keep commerce out. A 1931 Times roundup of Christmas sermons reported a common theme: "the suggestion that Christmas could not survive if Christ were thrust into the background by materialism." A 1953 Methodist sermon broadcast on NBC - typical of countless such sermons - lamented that Christmas had become a "profit-seeking period." This ethic found popular expression in "A Charlie Brown Christmas." In the 1965 TV special, Charlie Brown ignores Lucy's advice to "get the biggest aluminum tree you can find" and her assertion that Christmas is "a big commercial racket," and finds a more spiritual way to observe the day. http://select.nytimes.com/...
Node Created:	Ulysses Berman — 2005-12-12 21:25:23

Return to parent argument

Pending Arguments

There are no pending Arguments.

Create an Argument!

Argument Leaders

Ulysses Berman - 40
coolgeek - 19
smartypants - 8
J-Luck - 6
joetab24 - 5
wethion - 2
revisingproust - 2
geniusiknowit - 2

Node Leaders

Ulysses Berman - 403
coolgeek - 230
smartypants - 104
J-Luck - 88
joetab24 - 64
geniusiknowit - 16
revisingproust - 15
Grace - 12

Readings

Things to think about in our little corner of the cognitive surplus.

Gin, Television, and Social Surplus
"Media that's targeted at you but doesn't include you may not be worth sitting still for. [That has] become my motto, when people ask me what we're doing--and when I say "we" I mean the larger society trying to figure out how to deploy this cognitive surplus, but I also mean we, especially, the people in this room, the people who are working hammer and tongsat figuring out the next good idea."

Is Google Making Us Stupid?
"As the media theorist Marshall McLuhan pointed out in the 1960s, media are not just passive channels of information. They supply the stuff of thought, but they also shape the process of thought. And what the Net seems to be doing is chipping away my capacity for concentration and contemplation. My mind now expects to take in information the way the Net distributes it: in a swiftly moving stream of particles."

Site News

New Help docs
Honest Argument help documentation has been completely rewritten

New Node types
We've added two new Argument node types that point to separate Arguments

Move Arg Nodes
Now move Argument nodes within Arguments

Embeddable Diagrams
Embed Argument Diagrams on your site - or any other site

Argument Requests
Create an Argument Request for an Argument you would like to see. Or create an Argument from someone else's Request

Pending Arguments

New Arguments

Updated Arguments

Argument Requests

Argument Leaders

Node Leaders

Readings

Site News